Oversight beyond formal forums: Collaborative environmental governance of seaweed farming in a border district of Indonesia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.83835/bwn02k60Keywords:
Aquaculture, Governance, Indonesia, Oversight, TrustAbstract
Seaweed farming in Nunukan, a border district in North Kalimantan, Indonesia, involves many actors and is covered by provincial and district regulations, yet its oversight remains largely ad hoc and reactive. This study examines to what extent principles of collaborative environmental governance (CEG) are realised in the oversight of seaweed farming, and why community institutions appear to perform oversight functions more consistently than formal ones. Drawing on 71 interviews with 62 informants in three coastal sub-districts, complemented by document analysis, we assess five dimensions: involvement of local actors, collaborative forums, social learning, mutual trust and knowledge co-production. We identify four main findings. First, the oversight system is largely pre-collaborative: non-governmental organisations and academics are absent as independent actors, and the representation of farmers and fishers declines as decision arenas become more formal. Second, formal forums with a legal basis rarely produce traceable outputs, whereas community arrangements without legal status produce rules that are generally followed, such as compensation for damage and timing rules between farmers and harvesters. Third, trust is asymmetric: 24 of 40 field actors expressed low or no trust in local government, while trust among farmers remains relatively intact and relations between sea users differ across sub-districts. Fourth, scientific baselines are largely missing and the ecological observations of field actors are not recorded, so the two types of knowledge are seldom combined. We suggest that oversight could be strengthened by institutionalising multi-actor forums, linking informal and formal institutions rather than replacing them, making zoning and aid decisions more transparent, and building shared monitoring.
References
Ansell, C., Gash, A., 2018. Collaborative platforms as a governance strategy. J. Public Adm. Res. Theory 28 (1), 16–32.
Berenschot, W., van Klinken, G., 2018. Informality and citizenship: the everyday state in Indonesia. Citizsh. Stud. 22 (2), 95–111.
Bodin, Ö., 2017. Collaborative environmental governance: achieving collective action in social-ecological systems. Science 357 (6352), eaan1114.
Bodin, Ö., Robins, G., McAllister, R.R.J., Guerrero, A.M., Crona, B., Tengö, M., Lubell, M., 2016. Theorizing benefits and constraints in collaborative environmental governance: a transdisciplinary social-ecological network approach for empirical investigations. Ecol. Soc. 21 (1), 40.
Douglas, S., Berthod, O., Groenleer, M., Nederhand, J., 2020. Pathways to collaborative performance: examining the different combinations of conditions under which collaborations are successful. Policy Soc. 39 (4), 638–658.
Flannery, W., Healy, N., Luna, M., 2018. Exclusion and non-participation in marine spatial planning. Mar. Policy 88, 32–40.
Gerlak, A.K., Heikkila, T., Smolinski, S.L., Huitema, D., Armitage, D., 2018. Learning our way out of environmental policy problems: a review of the scholarship. Policy Sci. 51 (3), 335–371.
Hidayat, A.R., Hospes, O., Termeer, C.J.A.M., 2025. Why democratization and decentralization in Indonesia have mixed results on the ground: a systematic literature review. Public Adm. Dev. 45 (2), 159–172. https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.2095.
Langford, A., Zhang, J., Waldron, S., Julianto, B., Siradjuddin, I., Neish, I., Nuryartono, N., 2022. Price analysis of the Indonesian carrageenan seaweed industry. Aquaculture 550, 737828.
Newig, J., Challies, E., Jager, N.W., Kochskämper, E., Adzersen, A., 2018. The environmental performance of participatory and collaborative governance: a framework of causal mechanisms. Policy Stud. J. 46 (2), 269–297.
Partelow, S., 2018. A review of the social-ecological systems framework: applications, methods, modifications, and challenges. Ecol. Soc. 23 (4), 36.
Regional Regulation of North Kalimantan Province No. 4 of 2018 concerning the Zoning Plan for Coastal Areas and Small Islands of North Kalimantan Province for 2018–2038.
Regent Regulation of Nunukan Regency No. 28 of 2021 concerning Seaweed Farming.
Governor Regulation of North Kalimantan No. 26 of 2024 concerning Seaweed.
Siddiki, S., Kim, J., Leach, W.D., 2017. Diversity, trust, and social learning in collaborative governance. Public Adm. Rev. 77 (6), 863–874.
Steenbergen, D.J., Marlessy, C., Holle, E., 2017. Effects of rapid livelihood transitions: examining local co-developed change following a seaweed farming boom. Mar. Policy 82, 216–223.
Ulibarri, N., Emerson, K., Imperial, M.T., Jager, N.W., Newig, J., Weber, E., 2020. How does collaborative governance evolve? Insights from a medium-n case comparison. Policy Soc. 39 (4), 617–637.
Wyborn, C., Datta, A., Montana, J., Ryan, M., Leith, P., Chaffin, B., Miller, C., van Kerkhoff, L., 2019. Co-producing sustainability: reordering the governance of science, policy, and practice. Annu. Rev. Environ. Resour. 44, 319–346.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 IPM: Interdisciplinary Policy and Management, ILS Scientific Press an Imprint of CV. ILS NUSANTARA

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.














