Peer Review Process

Editorial Policy

Peer Review Process

Educational Interdisciplinary Journal applies a structured peer-review process to evaluate the quality, originality, relevance, and scholarly contribution of every submitted manuscript.

1. Overview

The peer-review process is an essential part of the editorial workflow of Educational Interdisciplinary Journal. It aims to ensure that manuscripts considered for publication meet appropriate standards of academic quality, methodological rigor, originality, and relevance to education and related interdisciplinary fields.

Editorial decisions are based on the academic merit of the manuscript, reviewer evaluations, and the journal's publication standards. Submission of a manuscript does not guarantee its acceptance or publication.

2. Manuscript Review Stages

1

Initial Editorial Screening

The editor checks the manuscript's relevance to the journal's aims and scope, compliance with submission requirements, originality, clarity of its scholarly contribution, and completeness of its essential components. Manuscripts that do not meet the basic requirements may be returned to the authors for correction or rejected at this stage.

 
2

Reviewer Assignment

Manuscripts that pass the initial screening may be assigned to reviewers with expertise relevant to the subject matter, including educational sciences, education policy and management, psychology and counseling, teaching and learning, educational technology, inclusive education, language and literacy, physical education, or other relevant fields. Reviewers are expected to assess manuscripts objectively, maintain confidentiality, disclose potential conflicts of interest, and provide constructive recommendations.

 
3

Reviewer Evaluation

Reviewers evaluate the manuscript's originality, relevance, theoretical foundation, research design, methodological rigor, accuracy of analysis, quality of discussion, clarity of presentation, and contribution to educational research and practice. For review articles and meta-analyses, reviewers also consider the transparency and appropriateness of the review methodology and synthesis procedures.

 
4

Editorial Decision

After considering the reviewer reports and the overall quality of the manuscript, the editor communicates the decision to the author. Possible decisions include acceptance, a request for minor or major revisions, or rejection. The editor retains responsibility for the final publication decision.

 
5

Revision and Final Evaluation

When revisions are required, authors must respond to the reviewers' comments and explain how each concern has been addressed. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the reviewers or evaluated by the editor, depending on the nature and extent of the revisions. Acceptance is confirmed only after the editor determines that the manuscript meets the journal's academic, technical, and ethical requirements.

3. Review Criteria

In evaluating a manuscript, reviewers consider the following criteria:

  • Relevance to the journal's aims and scope.
  • Originality and significance of the research contribution.
  • Clarity of the research questions, objectives, and arguments.
  • Appropriateness, validity, and transparency of the research methodology.
  • Quality of data analysis, interpretation, and discussion.
  • Contribution to educational theory, policy, practice, or interdisciplinary scholarship.
  • Use of relevant, credible, and current scholarly references.
  • Clarity, organization, and quality of academic writing.
  • Compliance with research ethics and publication standards.

4. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are responsible for ensuring that submitted manuscripts are original, accurate, ethically prepared, and not simultaneously under consideration by another journal. Authors must respond professionally to reviewer comments, submit revisions within the specified timeframe where applicable, and disclose funding information, conflicts of interest, and other required declarations.

Substantial changes made during revision must be adequately explained. Authors must not fabricate, falsify, manipulate, or misrepresent research data or findings. Authors remain responsible for the integrity and accuracy of their manuscripts throughout the editorial process.

5. Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers must provide fair, evidence-based, and constructive assessments. They must maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts under review, refrain from using unpublished information for personal advantage, identify relevant scholarly references that may have been omitted where appropriate, and promptly notify the editor if they cannot complete the review or identify a potential conflict of interest.

Reviewers provide recommendations to support editorial decision-making, while the final publication decision remains the responsibility of the editor.

6. Peer-Review Model

The journal's peer-review model and procedures should be stated clearly in its official editorial policy. If the journal adopts a double-anonymous review process, author identities are concealed from reviewers and reviewer identities are concealed from authors during the review. Authors should therefore remove identifying information from the review manuscript when required by the submission system.

7. Confidentiality and Conflicts of Interest

Information concerning submitted manuscripts, reviewer reports, and editorial deliberations must be kept confidential. Editors and reviewers must disclose actual or potential conflicts of interest that could affect the objectivity of the assessment. Where a conflict of interest exists, appropriate arrangements must be made to ensure an impartial evaluation process.

Commitment to Scholarly Quality

Educational Interdisciplinary Journal is committed to maintaining a fair, transparent, and academically rigorous peer-review process. Editorial decisions are guided by scholarly quality, research integrity, relevance to education, and the journal's publication standards.

 
Educational Interdisciplinary Journal
RESEARCH • PUBLISH • DEVELOP
Published by ILS Scientific Press — An Imprint of CV. ILS NUSANTARA